“Check the box and move on.”
Sound familiar? If you’re transitioning from public school to homeschooling, you might be tempted to measure success by how quickly you can check off every subject on your planner. But what if homeschooling could offer something deeper—like actual mastery of concepts? Let’s break down the difference, share a few fun real-life examples, and help you strike a balance that works for your family.
The Completion Mentality: Efficient But Superficial (It’s Not All Bad!)
Completion often looks like getting through assignments for the sake of saying, “It’s done.” It can be satisfying, but it sometimes lacks depth. Kids may “finish” the worksheet on long division but not fully understand why they’re carrying that one.
The Upside: Completion builds stamina and consistency. It teaches kids to follow through—a valuable life skill. Sometimes, completing a task (even if imperfectly) is better than stalling in pursuit of perfection.
The Downside: If completion is the sole focus, it can lead to surface-level understanding. Learning might not “stick,” and kids may need to revisit the material later. This is partly why public schools are denouncing memory work. Because kids “cram” to memorize for a test (completion) without understanding what it is they are memorizing (mastery) and thus forget the info as soon as the test is taken.
The Mastery Mindset: Deep but Slow (And That’s Okay!)
Mastery means sticking with a concept until it’s fully understood and confidently applied. It prioritizes depth over speed, allowing students to truly grasp material before moving forward.
The Upside: Mastery fosters genuine confidence and long-term retention. It helps students build a solid foundation for future learning and allows for creativity and exploration.
The Downside: It can feel slow, especially when you’re used to seeing daily checkmarks on a to-do list. You may worry your kids are “falling behind” (spoiler: they’re not!).
Three Real-Life Examples of Balance
- Reading Fluency
- Completion: Your child reads 20 minutes every day, even if they struggle with decoding words.
- Mastery: You pause daily reading time and spend two weeks focused on phonics games or specific sounds. Once they nail it, reading becomes faster and more enjoyable.
- The Balance: Combine the two! Use phonics games for 10 minutes, then enjoy storytime—even if you read to them. Both approaches build skills over time.
- Math Concepts
- Completion: Your child finishes a page of multiplication problems daily but still counts on their fingers.
- Mastery: You take a week to play with multiplication manipulatives or cook together using recipes to explore real-world math.
- The Balance: Complete three problems a day for consistency, then dive into mastery activities like baking a “fractions pie.”
- Essay Writing
- Completion: Your teen submits a five-paragraph essay every week, even if it’s riddled with grammatical errors.
- Mastery: You take one month to focus on structure and transitions, producing one well-crafted essay instead of four rushed ones.
- The Balance: Alternate weeks—one week, complete a quick essay; the next, refine it with a deep dive into editing skills.
How to Decide What Your Family Needs
- If Your Kids Thrive on Checkmarks: Keep a checklist but allow flexibility. Add small mastery moments within their daily routine.
- If Your Kids Crave Deep Dives: Start small with completion goals to avoid burnout and keep momentum.
- If You’re Stuck in Fear of Falling Behind: Spoiler alert—homeschoolers can’t “fall behind” because the finish line isn’t the same for everyone.
Need Help? Cure the Fear
If you’re feeling overwhelmed by the thought of balancing mastery and completion, grab a copy of Cure the Fear: How to Take Charge of Your Homeschool Journey. It’s packed with practical advice to help you overcome the fear of falling short and embrace a homeschool philosophy that works for YOU.
Recommended Class: Study Skills & Note-Taking for Success
True North Homeschool Academy offers a Study Skills & Note-Taking course that’s perfect for teaching kids how to balance completing assignments with truly mastering material. This class builds skills like goal-setting, organization, and active study techniques, ensuring that your students grow into independent learners ready for any challenge.
Final Thoughts
Homeschooling doesn’t have to be an all-or-nothing choice between mastery and completion. The beauty of homeschooling is that you get to tailor your approach to fit your family. So whether you’re checking boxes, diving deep, or (ideally) doing both, remember: you’re building something amazing.
Now, go bake that fractions pie and call it math class.
Lisa Nehring and her husband, Dr. David Nehring, a Clinical Psychologist, and Biblical Scholar speak together on a wide variety of topics, including education, classical education, vision, mission, parenting, marriage, and more.
- Mastery vs. Completion: Why Homeschooling Lets You Have the Best of Both Worlds - November 25, 2024
- Using Innovative Processes to Reboot Online Education - November 14, 2024
- Embracing Educational Freedom: A Conversation with Sam Sorbo - October 30, 2024
