How to Deal with Teenagers: Arrogance and Disrespect

“Well, just enjoy knowing everything now, because pretty soon you'll realize you're just as stupid as we are!!” said one father to his teenager.

(No, this didn't actually originally happen in our family; it was a friend of ours who said it to his daughter — but I may or may not have borrowed it a time or two, lol.)

Wow, teenagers can definitely often give off the impression that they think they know just about all there is to know, don't they? And we parents are so NOT worth listening to much of the time.

This can be a discouraging thing. Um, it can be a discouraging few years, actually.

And TBBH (to be brutally honest), even though I've dealt with five teenagers (my third just turned twenty, so there are two left currently in the midst of all of this), I still am aware that there is a lot I don't know about this issue.

In fact, if your teenager is a particularly difficult case, with extreme rebelliousness and/or frightening, harmful behavior patterns, then this post may not be for you. Your issues may be more serious than I can speak to. I will not be offended if you think what I say is too shallow or naive; in your case, that is probably true. But I suggest giving it a quick read, anyway, to see if there just might be a nugget you can use or some encouragement that will lift your heart for at least today.

I certainly don't consider myself the expert parent, y'all. (Personally, I don't see how anyone can seriously claim to be one, since kids are all SO different. Just sayin'…)

But based on my experience, let me throw out a few thoughts about how to deal with teenagers for your consideration:

First, it is important to remember WHY they are acting this way.

Because when we remember to see things from their perspective, it can help us deal with their arrogance in a more understanding way. Their behavior stems from probably a crazy mixture of multiple reasons:

  1. They are waking up to the world outside the family walls and realizing that it's pretty big, bigger than what they've been exposed to up to now. One of the ways this can play out is that they can think their own family life is boring compared to everything OUT THERE. And they let us know that in no uncertain terms, don't they?
  2. They are realizing mom and dad are not infallible (more on that later). You'd think they would have figured that out before now; but surprisingly, they haven't. LOL.
  3. They are unconfident and/or scared and/or intimidated. Yep, you read that right. When we are at our least confident, that's when we can be most obnoxious in our seeming confidence. We overcompensate for our insecurities by puffing ourselves off larger than we know ourselves to be. It's a human foible thing, possibly even a coping mechanism.
  4. They are immature. They don't realize just how much — but we do. It's painfully obvious due to their roller-coaster-like swings back and forth from writing a wonderful paper with profound thoughts to picking on their younger sibling for taking up too much space on the back seat of the car. This can be SO frustrating!
  5. They have just enough knowledge to be dangerous, lol. Actually it can be a serious thing. My husband talks about how the most dangerous time for a pilot is when he has 100 hours of flying time. He thinks he knows enough, and so he takes risks he really shouldn't. He doesn't know enough NOT to take them. And many learn that lesson the hard way. Our teens are similar. They can be so brash about things they know almost nothing about. That can be scary.
  6. Hormones, y'all. Do you remember what that was like? Emotions going crazy, self-control sometimes at a minimum, body changing, ZITS — it all conspires against their ability to process things with emotional intelligence. So glad I don't have to go through that again myself, aren't you? (Oh yea, there's menopause… let's just not talk about that.)

Related: Episode 82 – When Hormones and Homeschooling Collide

Another thing to keep in mind is that this is most likely just a phase.

I know that sounds simplistic, but I think a good majority of teens do grow out of this. Sometimes it takes longer, sometimes shorter — it obviously dependes on the individual kid and LOTSA other factors.

One of my favorite people, an older gentleman whom we have “adopted” as another grandparent, says that one of his adult daughters learns things the easy way, and the other learns them the hard way. As in, one avoids certain things and therefore saves herself a lot of difficulty; while the other tends to act first, and then by going THROUGH the difficulty, she learns the lesson to avoid that thing from then on. Many kids can still be like this after leaving home. Sometimes that's just the way it is.

But if we don't give up on them (read Teaching Diligence to My Teen is a Hill I am Willing to Die On for more about not giving up), I think we can help reduce the arrogance factor quite a bit before they have to face the world on their own and have it reduced for them by forces that might not be as nice as we are.

Related: Episode 70 – When Your Teen Disagrees with You

So how do we deal with this brash, over-confident, often disrespectful behavior that is driving us UP THE WALL??

With lots of love and patience.

I know this seems counterintuitive, especially when you want to wring their neck, lol — but during the teen years love and patience are the key to just about everything.

HUGS. LOTSA HUGS. Warm eyes and smiles in their direction. Candy dropped on their desk at odd moments. Touches on the shoulder as you pass by. LISTENING to them when they want to talk. (Translated: make the choice to LOOK AWAY from the computer/phone screen.) LOVE. Just love, unconditional and VERY generously given.

Related: Episode 81 – Communicating with Teenagers

Also, keep thinking about all those “reasons why” that we've already discussed, and don't expect them to change overnight. As with most things valuable, it might take awhile — as in YEARS. Keep trying, keep working with them, keep showing them lotsa love even when you want to ream them up one side and down the other.

Oh yes, and show them respect. This is HUGE.

YES, I get that they are being rude and obnoxious to everyone around them, especially to their parents. I get that they probably don't deserve respectful treatment from us. But as we treat THEM with respect despite their behavior, they will see that they can do that towards others, as well.

Be aware that I am NOT saying to refrain from giving them consequences for their actions and attitudes. What I am saying is even then we should strive to do it in a respectful way.

I will be painfully honest here. The truth is that I have been charaterized by getting loud. Um, VERY loud. But you know what? “The wrath of man does not achieve the righteousness of God” (James 1:20). Every time I lose my temper and yell, I am most likely NOT achieving righteousness in my child's life. I have forfeited an opportunity for growth. It literally is wasted words.

What is a thousand times better is to maintain an even keel and speak quietly and without disparaging words or tone. Without assumptions about their motivation. Just the facts, ma'am, nothing but the facts.

For me this is ridiculously difficult. But every time I have had self-control and treated my teens respectfully — in spite of their absolutely blatant obnoxiousness — good things have resulted. At the very least, bad things have been avoided. LOL.

Related: Episode 84 – Modeling Respect to Your Teen

Humility is also key. Yours, I mean. :-)

In fact, your humility and transparency can be the start of the turnaround. Admit you don't have it all together! Admit you can be a stupid idiot sometimes, even towards them! Tell them you are sorry, ask their forgiveness, be specific about how you have handled things badly. This is a heart softener, y'all!! I can't stress this enough!! I've written more about it in Parenting: Two Thing that should NEVER CHANGE as Your Family Grows. So yea.

Here's one specific thing I have done with each of my teens, and I believe it has helped them understand exactly what is going on — and what they need to figure out — during this phase. It's a conversation that I make a point of having early on, and repeat as necessary (lol):

I have told them, “OK, here's the deal. I realize that you are becoming aware at this point that your dad and I are not infallible. You used to think we were always right, and now you know for a fact that we are not. We have faults — big ones. We don't know everything. We do the wrong thing. We make the wrong decisions. We get angry for the wrong reasons. We are, in short, sinners.

So at this time in your life you have a decision to make. You have to DECIDE to respect us. Not because you think we deserve it, because you might not for awhile — but because it is the right thing to do. Just like a military soldier has to respect his commanding officer. Just like a worker has to respect their boss.

This is not going to be easy; I totally get that — but it is going to be better for you in the long run. Because the fact is that you don't know everything, either. And we still have been on this earth a lot longer than you have. So listen to us when we speak, and feel free to dialogue about something you don't agree with or don't understand. But do it RESPECTFULLY. That's the way to show us that you are indeed growing up and worthy of all of those privileges and rights you think you should have.”

There is something about meeting a teen on their level, of understanding their insides and not being critical of them, that helps them see that they don't have to know everything, either. They can be wrong, and that's OK. If they know you will treat them with care and understanding, not condemnation — because you are honest about your own failings — the arrogance can begin to melt away.

Is any of this easy? Not usually. For some of my teens it was easier, for some it still continues to be difficult. And I don't always come across as the adult, lol. It's all a work in progress, for them AND for us. Be patient with the process in BOTH of you.

Related: Episode 88 – Why and How to Apply Structure and Rules with Teens

Speaking of great parenting lines I have borrowed, here's another one, said by a mom to her four boys who were all born before she turned 23 and who now have multiple grandchildren of their own, making her a great-grand many times over: “Listen, I brought you into this world, and I can also take you out of it!!”

(I never said it seriously, of course. But it does give one a certain vicarious pleasure, doesn't it?? LOL.)


P.S. Here is my favorite book about parenting teens from a Christian perspective (referral link): Age of Opportunity, by Paul David Tripp.

It's Not That Hard to Homeschool

28 thoughts on “How to Deal with Teenagers: Arrogance and Disrespect”

  1. So much truth here, Ann! One thing I’ve implemented with my own teens is following up any negatives with a positive. For example, if I’ve had to have a hard talk or dole out consequences to a particular teen, I will often “just happen” to take them out for lunch or on an unexpected shopping trip, or even brag on some of their positive traits when I know they will overhear me. Works wonders, I tell you! :)

  2. Thank you for reminding us WHY teenagers act the way that they do. I am much more patient with our teen and tween daughters when I do not take their behavior personally! It is so important to create a family culture of mutual respect. Just teaching our girls how to disagree respectfully makes a huge difference in the tone of our home!

  3. I just had almost the same respect talk with my almost 12 year old dd. Humor and the ability to admit mistakes will always help in life.

        1. GOODNESS! THe link for that book had literally disappeared! I am SO sorry! I’ve added it now to the end of the article, and for convenience, I’ll also put it here. The book is called Age of Opportunity, and the author is Paul David Tripp. You can find it on Amazon here (referral link): THANKS SO MUCH for pointing that out to me!

  4. The Christian book on parenting that you recommended is not showing. Could you please telll me the title. Thanks for this!

  5. Thanks! This really helped. I am just aiming to follow this and need to do much more…! I appreciate your sharing!😊

  6. Thank u so much. I dont have a teenage kid. But i’ve been looking for ways to correct one of my students. Ur post has been very useful.

  7. Giving unconditional love at the expense of being victimized by constant disrespectful abuse is exactly the opposite advice given to battered spouses who need help to understand they must leave the relationship. Life is full of consequences for actions. Trouble is the suffering to be endured by the respectful kids that grow up and meet and have relationships with the disrespectful abusers parented with advice given here.

    1. Of course, Randall, I am super aware that there are cases more severe than what this post speaks to. I did say that in the post. I personally think “disrespectful abusers” may grow up to be that way regardless of the parenting they receive. Thanks for stopping by.

    2. I completely agree. Love does not cure all!! This generation of teens has been given a pass allowing them to treat their parents horribly and then it’s all explained away with hormones and a lack of experience. I felt compelled to comment because I was looking for an article that would help me with my teenage boy and reading this clarified why most of these kids act the way they do! None of us have the guts to parent anymore. Myself included. There is no mention of tough love and not tolerating these behaviors.

      1. Hi Jess, I think we have to be careful what we’re talking about here. I definitely believe in “having the guts to parent,” but here we are talking about attitudes, not actions. It’s hard to give consequences for attitudes because it is impossible to be objective about them. In fact, giving “tough love” for attitudes is in my opinion going to hurt the relationship, possibly to the point of no return. Now, if you want to read about consequences for behavior, then you might be interested in this: Teaching Diligence to My Teen is a Hill I am Willing to Die On.

  8. Thank you so much for sharing. I relate to everything here and am trying to be a better parent to my teens. I am recently remarried and the teen dynamics have put a strain on my household. My husband acts like a teen himself as he lets their attitude get the best of him and falls right into the teen trap. This has been very difficult for me as he expects me to “fix”
    their teenage attitudes and I just can’t. If it was only that simple. I will be practicing remaining calm and hope he can learn to do the same. I am praying we can overcome but am also realizing that it may not be possible if he doesn’t try to do things different. Living on Faith! Thank you for the reminders. God Bless.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Share via
Copy link